Welcome to Rocky's New York Pizza
Rocky's New York Pizza embodies the essence of casual Italian dining, serving up a delightful range of pizza and hearty subs. This long-standing establishment has become a local favorite in Hagerstown, known for its New York-style pizza that satisfies cravings without burning a hole in your wallet. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or enjoying a cozy dinner with family, Rocky's offers a friendly, bustling atmosphere. The extensive menu caters to various tastes, featuring everything from cheesy slices to satisfying lasagna. With quick service and a casual vibe, it's the perfect spot for a solo meal or a gathering with friends, capturing the charm of a classic neighborhood pizzeria.
Popular dishes
Restaurant Gallery
About
Located at 907 S Potomac St, Rocky's New York Pizza stands out in Hagerstown for its authentic NYC-style pizza. This family-friendly joint attracts everyone from locals to college students, thanks to its welcoming atmosphere and delicious offerings. The accessible features, including a wheelchair-friendly entrance and seating, make it inviting for all guests. Rocky's operates every day of the week, with delivery and takeaway options for those on the go and dine-in service for those who prefer a casual sit-down experience. Bright, cozy lighting and trendy decor create a relaxed environment, perfect for enjoying a slice or two. Plus, the laid-back charm is complemented by friendly service that makes you feel right at home. Whether you’re indulging in a Friday night dinner with friends or a solo lunch, Rocky's caters to all dining preferences.
Location & Contact
Address
907 S Potomac St, Hagerstown, MD 21740, United States
Hotline
+1 301-791-6810
Working Hours
- SundayOpen
- MondayOpen
- TuesdayOpen
- WednesdayOpen
- ThursdayOpen
- FridayOpen
- SaturdayOpen
What People Say
Most Liked
Many patrons rave about the generous portion sizes, especially the 2 slices and a drink for just $7—a deal that keeps customers returning for more. The crust’s perfect balance of chewiness and crispness consistently earns high praises, often described as the best in Hagerstown. Diners also appreciate the aromatic sauce that sets the pizza apart, enhancing the overall flavor. The extensive menu keeps people coming back; familiar Italian classics like lasagna and subs complement the standout pizzas. Fast service and a friendly staff round out the positive experience, making guests feel valued and appreciated.
Most Disliked
A few diners have noted the seasoning on certain hot subs, particularly the steak and cheese, could use a bit more finesse to elevate the dish's flavor. Additionally, during peak business hours, wait times can extend as customers flock to savor the pizza, which may lead to a slightly slower service experience. Some visitors mention a desire for a broader selection of gourmet toppings on the pizzas, pointing out that though the classics are beloved, they would enjoy a little variety. Despite these minor drawbacks, most reviews highlight the overall satisfaction with food quality, emphasizing that these concerns don't overshadow the delightful dining experience.
Reviews
Jess h.
Rocky's is a classic! I love their 2 slice and drink for $7. The slices are the perfect size. Everyone is so nice, and they brought our food, piping hot, right to the table!
Robert G.
Without a doubt, the most authentic NYC-style pizza in Hagerstown. Over the past few months I've been trying as many pizza joints between Falling Waters and the Mason-Dixon Line as I can try. This Rocky's location features the best crust and definitely the best sauce. The sauce is light, aromatic, herbal, and tastes great even when reheated. The pizza smells amazing. The textures and ratios are perfect. The sauce is definitely what sets Rocky's on South Potomac apart from all the others.
Tammy E.
I stopped here today on my way from Pennsylvania to Virginia and I’m glad I did! I haven’t had really good pizza since moving from out west. I shall return!
NiccolosMoraOfficial
Over all the best pizza I've had in Hagerstown, good dough, i can taste the difference. Pretty good pizza and steak n cheese. Wish there was a tad bit more seasoning on the steak n cheese. Overall, I will go back. Great food great atmosphere. Great price $26 for a philly steakncheese and medium pepperoni pizza.
Dawson H.
The food here is top tier! Definitely would recommend it to anyone who resides in Hagerstown! Love from Martinsburg, West Virginia
Knatty L.
Delicious sub & pizza. First time visiting this location. Food was awesome
Glamma M.
We just moved to the area July 10,2023 and today was our first time ordering from here. The half and half pizza was SO GOOD we also loved how there was little red sauce.